ADR-0074 — The repo family realized: producer workspace and skills catalog
- Sections
- 5
- Format
- Markdown
- Order
- 110 / 156
Context
ADR-0073 named the multi-repo workspace and noted that the Suspec family's own was "a separate
owner action." The owner acted: a suspec-works repo now exists for the family (suspec · suspec-cli ·
suspec-skills · planned: suspec-starter-kit, suspec-ci, suspec-website). Until now this repo carried
its own producer workspace (.agents/specs|audits|change-plans) and two skill surfaces beyond
the kit core (the kit's advanced/ guides; docs/library/code-skills/), and suspec-cli carried a
full co-located workspace. The repo-split audit (now at suspec-works:specs/repo-split-architecture/audit.md)
states the governing principle: suspec is canon; every other repo is derived, implemented, or
indexed from it — and a producer workspace inside the product repo ships planning clutter to
the adopters and the CLI that consume it.
Decision
- The producer workspace is
suspec-works— the family's multi-repo workspace (the ADR-0073 shape applied to Suspec itself). Specs, audits, research, change plans, findings, tasks, reviews, and the board for changes to this repo and to suspec-cli live there. This repo and suspec-cli carry the code-repo footprint (the workspace pointer, the gitignore lines, theimplement-taskguide) — nothing else. Accepted framework decisions still land here, indocs/adrs/;suspec-worksis not a second canon. - The optional guides are a catalog:
suspec-skills. The kit'sadvanced/guides and the per-change-shape implementation guides (formerlydocs/library/code-skills/) move to thesuspec-skillsrepo in the Agent Skills format (skills/<name>/SKILL.md), installable piecemeal (npx skills add jcosta33/suspec-skills) or by copying folders. The kit keeps the three core guides;starter-kit/advanced/keeps the optional templates and the two reference cards and points at the catalog for guides.docs/library/is retired. - The dev subset shrinks to implementation-side guides.
.agents/skills/keepsimplement-task(byte-identical kit mirror),empirical-proof, andpersona-documentarian. The authoring, review, and persona guides move tosuspec-works's skills as workspace-adapted copies — spec writing, reviewing, and auditing for this repo run from the workspace.
Alternatives considered
- Keep the producer workspace co-located — the dogfooding default, but this repo is not a normal adopter: its product is copied wholesale by adopters and consumed by the CLI, so producer artifacts pollute the product surface; the audit's observation 2 makes the boundary explicit.
- Per-repo full installs across the family — rejected by ADR-0073 Decision 6: one full workspace, footprints in code repos, no install in derived-content repos.
- Advanced guides stay in the kit — every adopter carries guides they do not need, and the catalog cannot grow without growing every workspace copy; the kit stays core-only, the catalog installs piecemeal.
- A
suspec-linterrepo — rejected; record-level checks belong in suspec-cli (suspec spec check), per the audit and ADR-0058's notation-not-language framing.
Consequences
Accepted. Refines ADR-0064 (minimal kit tiering — the optional tier's guides now distribute
via the catalog; the tier's templates and cards stay in the kit), ADR-0069 (kit contents unchanged in shape; the
advanced directory's guide subfolders leave), and ADR-0073 (the family's own multi-repo
workspace exists). The propagation surfaces — docs/01/03/05/07/08, ADOPTING, agent-guides,
review-stances, advanced-lifecycle, kit README, advanced README, the skills manifest, this
repo's AGENTS.md — now point at the workspace and the catalog. suspec-cli's uninstall is
recorded in its own history.
Propagation
AGENTS.md (workspace pointer, pointers, single-sourcing), docs/01, docs/03, docs/05, docs/07, docs/08, docs/ADOPTING.md, docs/reference/{agent-guides, review-stances, advanced-lifecycle}, starter-kit/README.md, starter-kit/advanced/README.md, .agents/SKILLS-MANIFEST.md, ledger row.
Starter kit: Set up a workspace